Hong Kong: the Umbrella Revolution

Ho avuto il piacere di conversare con Luca Caldironi (psichiatra/psicoanalista SPI) a proposito di psicoanalisi, cultura cinese, rivoluzione degli ombrelli, arte e molto altro. Potete leggere l'intervista direttamente sul sito della SPI (Societa' Psicoanalitica Italiana):

http://www.spiweb.it/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=5316%3Ahong-kong-la-rivoluzione-degli-ombrelli&catid=802&Itemid=907

Physical spaces and mental space. How Hong Kong people deal with high density living.

 (A research project)

The relations between psychoanalysis and architecture have been largely underestimated. Architecture cannot simply be considered as the "projection of the architect's unconscious mind"; nor are we interested to what is called the "architecture of the mind". Psychoanalysis goes beyond the "perspective" and the "point of view". Both psychoanalysis and architecture are science of the speech; both indicate how things are being written. We aim at a psychoanalysis and architecture without representation.

I present here an attempt to a research project to investigate in a original and more productive way the relations between psychoanalysis and architecture:

Abstract

The urban area of Hong Kong has one of the highest population and employment density in the world. As of 2013, there are more than seven million people for its 1,068 square kilometres (412 square miles) of land. There is a myth that high population density is often associated with social pathologies and problems. However, only studies on animals have proven this association. There is little correlation between density and social pathology – deviant behavior, crime and suicide – when other socioeconomic variables are considered. This is particularly true in Hong Kong, where the very high density of development has not been accompanied by many of the social illnesses expected in the Western experience. The Hong Kong Chinese have not eliminated tension, stress and conflict, but they have developed ways for managing effectively space, time and people.

However, some variables suggest that high density living has effects on the human mind and the psychological development of individuals.

What are the relations between the living conditions of Hong Kong (the external, physical space) and its effects on the psychology of people (the inner, mental space)? How do the Hong Kong Chinese cope with living in a high density place? What psychological consequences it has? How do people prevent or manage conflicts in relationship? What is the price to pay for pursuing harmonious relationships in a high density living? Is high density living related to the level of awareness of one’s own unconscious desires and feelings?

Research Objectives

The Chinese have developed some strategies for coping with high density living (Anderson, 1972). Literature describes Hong Kong culture as very practical, concrete (Hall and Ames, 1998; Liang, Cherian and Liu, 2010; Jullien, 2004/b) and money oriented (Chen, 1995; Yeh and Wang, 2000). Life is fast paced and hongkongers are normally described as hardworking. The social structure of Hong Kong has perhaps favored interdependency among people, rather than developing individual critical thinking (Nakarama, in Redding 1990). Hong Kong Chinese culture is flattened on a horizontal, relational level, and apparently less concerned than European or North American cultures with understanding or analyzing transcendence or inner reality (Busiol, 2013). More than in other cultures, the social network is central for the Chinese (Yeung, et al, 2012), and feelings of acceptance, trust (Fang and Faure, 2010; Fukuyama, 1995; Ke and Zhang, 2003), and hope are emphasized over the content of communication (Mok, Wong, and Wong, 2010; Tong, Hung, and Yuen, 2010). The Hong Kong Chinese show a peculiar attitude toward speaking and listening (Busiol, 2013), distinctive help seeking behaviors (Cheng, Lo and Chio, 2010), and preference for passive coping strategies; they are oriented toward “solving” rather than “analyzing” problems (Ho, Tsui, Chu, Chan 2003), and evaluate practical problems more than emotional problems. The Chinese thought developed for providing answers (for regulating a way of living together, for example), rather than posing questions; efficiency and practicality are emphasized. Direct communication is often avoided. There is a great concern for meeting others’ expectations in order to obtain social acceptance, maintain relational harmony, and avoid social sanctions (Hwang and Han, 2010).

Understandably, harmony in relationships becomes a very important value when living in places with high density, so it became a keyword in the Hong Kong Chinese culture; but, at the individual level what is the price of pursuing social harmony? A series of social phenomena may indicate the need to redesign a mental space different or alternative to the physical space in which people live, which is not enough. The phenomena of “hidden youths” (reclusive adolescents or young adults who withdraw from social life, often seeking extreme degrees of isolation and confinement; see Wong, 2009), the internet addictions (Cheung, Chiu and Lee, 2011), and the continuous and almost uninterrupted use of the phone, just to name a few, can be interpreted as different attempts to recreate a virtual space (giving different limits and barriers) where the current living space is lacking. Such phenomena allow at the same time higher proximity (everybody seems so close, anytime) and higher distance (the connection can be interrupted anytime; it is not too intrusive; it can help to overcome shyness) from others; thus, these can be ways for taking distance from situations deemed too invasive, and ways to create one’s own privacy.

One hypothesis is that high density living reflect in a reduced inner space and a reduced attitude toward cultivating inner feelings and desires. This research aims at clarify the relations between living in high density and the need for harmony on one hand, and the need to redesign a virtual space, which is also an inner, space with different barriers and limits on the other hand.

It is expected that pursuing harmony is reflected in lower awareness and expression of unconscious feeling and a reduced attitude toward questioning, so as to avoid conflicts. Furthermore, it is expected that long working hours are also a consequence of lower personal space at home. The variable trust is also expected to be correlated to the great concern for securing a safe space for one’s own. Finally, it is expected that the use of internet is very high because it allows to a virtual space that overcome the lack of physical space and barriers and distance from others.

  

Practical relevance

This perspective helps to debunk some myths about high density living and investigates more in depth some issues that have been only partially or superficially analyzed. Previous research on Hong Kong show that high density, if better planned and managed, can be an interesting and pleasant environment. However, previous research only focused on external, observable behaviors, and were not able to highlight and investigate the dynamics between people and the effects of reduced living space on individuals and the unconscious mind. This research bridges architecture and psychology/psychoanalysis and shed some light on the implications and consequences of high density living.

Results are pragmatic because they show how the external space is perceived by individuals and reflected in the inner world. A reduced living space does not necessarily lead to social pathology, or higher mental illness, as incorrectly assumed in the past. However, it does not go without consequences on the mind, and this research aims at showing what such consequences may be.

References

Abbas, A. (1994). Building on Disappearance: Hong Kong Architecture and the City. Public Culture, 6(3): 441-59.

Anderson, E.N. (1972). Some Chinese methods of dealing with crowding. Urban Anthropology, 1 , 141-150.

Busiol, D. (2013). Is Psychoanalysis missing from counseling in Hong Kong? 在香港的心理輔導中，心理分析是否遺漏了呢? City University of Hong Kong. PhD thesis, unpublished.

Chang, C. (2001). Harmony as performance, the turbulence under Chinese interpersonal communication. Discourse Studies, 3(2), 155-179, Sage, London.

Chen, C.P. (1995). Group counseling in a different cultural context. Several primary issues dealing with Chinese clients. Group, 19, 1,45-55.

Cheng, C., Lo, B. C.Y. and Chio, J.H.M. (2010). The Tao (ways) of Chinese coping. In: Bond, M.H. (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Chinese Psychology, (pp. 399-419), New York, Oxford University Press.

Cheung, C.M.K, Chiu, P.Y. and Lee M.K.O. (2011). Online social networks, Why do students use Facebook? Computers in Human Behavior, 27, 1337-1343.

Cheung, S. (2001). Problem-solving and solution focused therapy for Chinese, recent development. Asian Journal of counseling, 8(2), 111-128.

Fang, T. and Faure, G.O. (2010). Chinese communication characteristics, A yin yang perspective. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 35(3), 329-333.

Fukuyama, F. (1995). Trust, the Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity. The Free Press.

Hall, D.L. and Ames R.T. (1998). Thinking from the Han, self, truth, and transcendence in Chinese and Western culture. Albany, State University of New York Press.

Ho, W.S., Tsui, M.S., Chu, C.K. and Chan, C.C. (2003). Towards culturally sensitive EAP counselling for Chinese in Hong Kong. Employee Assistance Quarterly, 18(4), 73-83.

Hwang, K.K. and Han, K.H. (2010). Face and Morality in Confucian society. In: Bond, M.H. (Ed.), The handbook of Chinese Psychology, (pp.479-498). New York, Oxford University Press .

Jullien, F. (2004/b) Treatise on Efficacy, Between Western and Chinese Thinking, Honolulu, University of Hawai'i Press.

Ke, R., Zhang W. (2003). Trust in China, A Cross-Regional Analysis. William Davidson Institution Working Paper No. 586. Available at http, //ssrn.com/abstract=57781i

Leong, F.T. (1986). Counseling and psychotherapy with asian-Americans, review of the literature. Journal of Counseling psychology, 33, 196-206.

Liang, B., Cherian, J., Liu, Y. (2010). Concrete Thinking or Ideographic Language, Which is the Reason for Chinese People's Higher Imagery Generation Abilities? International Journal of Consumer Studies, 34(1), 52-60.

Mok, E., Wong, F., Wong, D. (2010). The meaning of spirituality and spiritual care among the Hong Kong Chinese terminally ill. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 66(2), 360-370.

Redding, G. (1990). Management education for orientals. In: Garratt, B. and Stopford, J. (eds), Breaking Down Barriers, Aldershot, Gower.

Tong, K.K., Hung, P.W., Yuen, S.M. (2011). The Quality of Social Networks, Its Determinants and Impacts on Helping and Volunteering in Macao. Social Indicators Research, 102, 351-361. Doi, 10.1007/s11205-010-9686-4

Wong, V. (2009). Youth locked in time and space? Defining features of social withdrawal and practice implications. Journal of Social Work Practice, 23, 337–352.

Yeh, C.J. and Wang, Y.W. (2000). Asian American coping attitudes, sources, and practices, Implications for indigenous counseling strategies. Journal of College Student Development, 41, 94-103.

Yeung, E, Irvine, F, Ng, S, Tsang, S (2012). Role of social networks in the help-seeking experiences among Chinese suffering from severe mental illness in England: A qualitative study. British Journal of Social Work, 43(3):486.